SuppleGut Take the quiz

Stool form and regularity

Metamucil 4-in-1 Sugar-Free Orange Powder

The pharmacy-shelf psyllium: the fiber with the strongest constipation evidence, flavored, sweetened and sold with an OTC laxative label.

Metamucil 4-in-1 Sugar-Free Orange Powder
Format
Powder
Type
Fiber
Cost
$23.10 for the 15 oz tub (36 servings), about $0.64 a day
Customer rating
See the reviews on iHerb

Not sure it suits your symptoms? The quiz matches one product to you in one to three minutes.

Why it might work

Psyllium husk forms a viscous gel that resists fermentation and keeps holding water all the way through the colon, so stools become softer and bulkier; the same gel in the small intestine binds bile acids, which is the cholesterol mechanism. That is the ingredient in Metamucil, and everything else in the tub is there to make it orange, sweet and pourable. One teaspoon is a smaller dose than a serving of plain husk, so the pack directs up to three a day.

What the trials show

Strong evidence for psyllium the ingredient, not for the brand. A meta-analysis of 16 randomized trials in 1,251 people with chronic constipation found responders at 66% against 41% on placebo, and the 2023 AGA/ACG guideline names psyllium as the one fiber supplement that appears to be effective. Psyllium also carries an FDA-authorized cholesterol claim at 7 g of soluble fiber a day, which the pack prints. No trial of the Metamucil formulation as sold was found; the evidence applies because the active fiber is the same.

What the label discloses

The OTC drug label declares approximately 3.4 g of psyllium husk per rounded teaspoon, 3 g of total fiber and 2 g of soluble fiber; other ingredients are maltodextrin, citric acid, natural and artificial orange flavor, aspartame and Yellow 6. The pack states it is gluten-free and prints the FDA cholesterol claim. Sold as an OTC bulk laxative with a filed Drug Facts panel. No third-party testing is stated.

Read more on the plants in the formula.

Who this tends to suit

The quiz pairs it with answers that mention constipation, irregular bowel habits, a feeling of incomplete emptying and bloating. It is scored for a goal of regularity or a steady daily routine. Whether it is the best fit for you depends on the rest of your answers — what you have already tried, what format you will take, and anything that has to be ruled out.

Where it may not fit

The label supports gluten-free. Like any powder, it depends on being taken as often as the label directs.

Reactions and warnings

It is psyllium husk with maltodextrin, orange flavor, aspartame (25 mg phenylalanine per teaspoon) and Yellow 6; plain psyllium powder gives more than twice the fiber per serving for less money. One teaspoon is about 3.4 g of psyllium and 3 g of fiber; the pack counts three servings a day toward the 7 g of soluble fiber behind the cholesterol claim. It must be taken with a full glass of liquid or it can swell and block the throat, and the label warns of allergic reactions in people sensitive to psyllium.

Is 4-in-1 Sugar-Free Orange Powder the one, or is something else?

The quiz weighs your symptoms and routine and names one match, which may or may not be 4-in-1 Sugar-Free Orange Powder.

Take the quiz →

Free, private, and it names one product.

Alternatives in the same role

Stool form and regularity: that is the job Metamucil 4-in-1 Sugar-Free Orange Powder does, and these are the other entries doing it.

See all the products we have researched →

Head-to-head comparisons

Side-by-side reads that put Metamucil 4-in-1 Sugar-Free Orange Powder or a close stand-in against the product people most often weigh it against.

Background reading

Where the numbers on this page come from, explained at length.

Guide Which psyllium husk should you buy? Plain husk powder, flavored Metamucil or capsules: what a serving of each contains, what a day costs, and what to check on the label before you buy. Guide Does Benefiber work? What wheat dextrin does and does not do Does Benefiber work? It adds 6 g of taste-free fiber to any drink, but the constipation trials found effects for psyllium and pectin, not wheat dextrin. What it is, the label dose, the gas question and what to buy instead for regularity. Guide Metamucil dosage: how much to take, in powder, capsules or gummies Metamucil dosage from the labels: one teaspoon of powder (about 3.4 g of psyllium) up to three times a day, five capsules (about 2.6 g) one to three times a day, and gummies with no psyllium at all. How that compares with the 10 g a day the trials used. Guide Does ColonBroom work? What is in the scoop and what the psyllium trials say ColonBroom is psyllium husk, the fiber with the strongest constipation evidence, but a scoop holds 3.6 g against 10 to 40 g a day in the psyllium trials. Guide Does SoWell Fiber work? Five grams of fiber, GLP-1 constipation and what the trials show SoWell Fiber has 5 g of fiber a packet from an undisclosed blend; trials point to over 10 g a day, and none tested fiber on semaglutide or tirzepatide. Guide Does Yerba Prima psyllium work? One ingredient, a 5 g teaspoon, and the dose the trials used Yerba Prima is plain psyllium husk. One 5 g teaspoon is half the 10 g a day the trials used, so two or three servings reach it, about $0.59 a day for two. Guide Does Bio.me Psyllium Husk Fiber work? Six and a half grams of psyllium, electrolytes, and the ten-gram trials One serving has 6.5 g of psyllium, under the 10 g a day used in the IBS trial. Two servings reach 13 g. No trial of the product exists. Guide Does Soothe & Renew work? A fiber powder whose label prints no psyllium amount, and the trials that used about 10 g No trial tested the blend, and the label gives 7 g of fiber with no psyllium amount. The brand page shows 4.73 from 255 reviews. Guide Does Pinch Magic Fiber work? A 5 g psyllium powder with no trial of its own, and trials that used 10 g or more No trial tested Pinch, and the psyllium trials used 10 g or more a day against its 5 g. The brand page shows 4.9 from 1,004 reviews. Guide Does Vacation Mornings work? A travel stick with 2 g of psyllium, and what 68 buyers reported No trial of the stick exists, and its psyllium and magnesium sit well below trial doses. Its 68 verified buyer reviews average 2.88 of 5.